Open Question: Who has a shot at having a career? Ashley or Vanessa?

Ok so I personally think Vanessa is doing more work to break out of the Disney mold and actually have a careerAshley to me isn't doing anything but promoting an album that only a bunch of tweens are gonna buy I mean she seems like shes trying so hard to be seen as sexy where as it seems like looking sexy just comes naturally to Vanessa.Does anyone else think Ashley's trying to hard?Sorta like shes trying to get rid of her tween fans,I know shes like 25,30 whatever and she has mature fans but come on most of them are between the ages of like 7-14.I just think she shouldn't try so hard because shes already really pretty(even though with the nose she looks a little weird when she smiles like its a struggle) And she has a nice enough voice though the whole rock thing to me doesn't suit her..Neither does singing it live..ouchSo what do you guys think Do you think we will still be talking about Ashley in 5 years or VanessaVanessa upcoming projects1.Bandslam-In theaters August 14-costarring Aly Michalka and Lisa Kudrow (David Bowie makes a cameo)2.Beastly-currently filming in Montreal-costarring Alex Pettyfer,Mary-Kate Olsen,and Neil Patrick Harris-In theaters July 30 20103.Sucker Punch-Filming right after Beastly in Vancouver-Rated R film-Directed by Zack Snyder(300,Watchmen)-Costarring Emily Browning,Abbie Cornish,Jena Malone,and Jamie Chung-In theaters March 25 20114.Dead@17-based on Josh Howard's Viper Comics Series-Josh recently confirmed shed be in it-produced by Lorenzo di Bonaventura(Transformers,G.I. Joe)-screenplay developed by Mark Dougherty(X-Men 2)Last two magazine coversSelfInstyle UKNoteworthy-Attended the Golden Globes this yearPerformed at the Oscars this yearMade Peoples 100 Most Beautiful List in 2008-No Makeupand 2009Maxim Hot 1002008-122009-27Made Maxim hot young Hollywood specialNumber 20 on Forbes "High Earners Under 30".in 2008Number 62 in FHMs sexiest women in the world in 2008Number 42 in 2009Endorsements-Ecko RedNuetrogenaSearsAwardsTeen ChoiceChoice Chemistry(with Zac)-2006Choice Music Breakout Artist-2007Choice Hottie-2008Kids ChoiceFavorite Movie Actress-2009German TV Channel-Best ActressNominations2006 IMAGEN Award-Best Television Actress2006 Teen Choice-Breakout Star2007 Young Artist Award-Best Performance in a TV Movie, Miniseries or Special-Leading Young Actress2008 MTV Music Awards-Video of the year for Sneakernight2009 MTV Movie Awards-Breakthrough PerformanceBest Kiss-with Zac2009 Teen Choice Awards-Choice Music/Dance Movie ActressChoice Liplock with ZacChoice HottieChoice Celebrity PetAshley's upcoming projectsAliens in the Attic-Rated G-Family Friendly-costarring Robert Hoffman and Doris Roberts-script written by Mark Burton and Adam F. GoldbergGuilty Pleasure-Sophomore album-single Its Alright Its Ok-to be released July 28-describes it as more edgier and rock-co wrote songs with American Idol judge Kara DioguardioLast two magazine coversShapeCosmopolitanNoteworthyDebut Album came in at Number 5 on the Billboard chartsAttended the Screen Actors Guild Awards in 2008Maxim Hot 100 in 2008-number 10Number 73 in 2009FHMs Sexiest Women in The World 2009 number 58Number 94 in Forbes Celebrity 100 list in 2008Number 17 in Forbes Highest Earners Under 30 in 2008Had a rhinoplasty or septoplasty in 2007 for a deviated septumsome people believe that she only did it to fix her nose because she didnt like-I think she really did have a deviated septumEndorsementsFormer Ecko Red spokespersonDegree Girl?Puerco Espin-Italian clothing lineAwardsUk Kids Choice Awards-Best TV Actress(Suite Life)-2007MTV Movie Awards-Breakthrough Performance-2009NominationsYoung Artist Awards-Best Performance in a TV Drama-Boston Public-2000Premios Oye!-International Breakthrough Artist 2007-HeadstrongTeen Choice Awards-Choice Music/Dance Movie Actress-2009So whats your opinion?Ashley Or Vanessa in 5 years?or both?Also the 2009 Teen Choice Awards are still open for voting and the results will air live on August 10 I think so for now they are just nominated